An appeal for individual responsibility
Does the industry need mandatory quality and environmental standards? It is not a new discussion, but it is becoming more relevant again as the market is veering towards wellness and selfcare.
Does the industry need mandatory quality and environmental standards? It is not a new discussion, but it is becoming more relevant again as the market is veering towards wellness and selfcare.
Colleen Godin, EAN U.S. Correspondent
While regulations would ultimately benefit everyone, even those in favor wonder if there‘s a way to create a regulatory system that‘s affordable and enforceable. Sex educator Linnea Marie is first off the starting line with enthusiasm, chiming in: “Absolutely! Now that I am buying for a medical clinic, I have to be extra diligent with materials.”
However, positive sentiments are quick to turn grim when reality sets in. Carolyn Eagle of Betty‘s Toy Box shares her thoughts: “As much as I want to say yes, I can’t imagine who would enforce the standards or how.” Eagle has a point that‘s echoed by many others. “I get the idea, but I’m guessing many manufacturers will put on a sticker or logo saying the product is approved when it actually won’t be,” says AVN‘s Kim Airs. Leave it to a distributor to finally call out the writing on the wall, as Nathan Morimitsu of Eldorado cuts right to the chase. “If there isn‘t a strong government regulatory body somewhere in the world demanding it, it will never happen,” says Morimitsu.
“An industry group could take the initiative, but that would require a financial commitment I‘m not sure is feasible.” Staci Cruse of Blush still believes a retail world that only touts healthy adult products is possible, but that future lies in the hands of those who are the true heart and soul of our industry.
“I have made it a point to work for companies that have these regulations in place and are tested to prove that they are safe for the intended use,” says Cruse. “It’s on us as sales reps, manufacturers, and buyers to make sure the end user has products that are safe for them.”
Matthias Johnson, editor in chief
First of all, let me strike a blow for our industry. There has been great progress when it comes to safety and quality standards in recent years, and environmental aspects are also taken much more seriously. Granted, most of these developments were largely driven by the consumers because companies and brands can ill afford to ignore the needs and expectations of their customer base.
And yes, every now and then, legislators force the industry in a new direction. But none of this lessens the achievements that have been made in this industry regarding safe ingredients and materials, not to mention sustainability. No one will deny that there is still room for improvement, but why would we need mandatory standards for that? Firstly, just take a look at the great strides this market has already taken without any legal obligation.
And secondly, producers and brands would be faced with even more bureaucratic hoops to jump through. Moreover, it wouldn’t be at all surprising if production cost went up significantly, and that in turn would mean that consumers had to reach even deeper into their pockets. In the worst case, price- conscious consumers would be driven away from the product category altogether. Of course, some might opt for cheap products of dubious quality instead.
But that is not in the interest of the market either, is it?
Do you want to be regularly informed? Then subscribe to our interesting newsletter: